Every18 equipment reviews
Putter reviews and stability rankings
Compare blade, mallet, high-MOI, and alignment-focused putter families by feel, stability, value, and fit profile.
58entries
90avg score
$198avg used price
TaylorMadetop family
Putters comparison
Compare score, estimated used price, fit profile, and fitting notes side by side.
| Metric | TaylorMade Spider X2019ReviewShop affiliate* | Cleveland HB Soft Premier2021ReviewShop affiliate* | PING PLD Milled2022ReviewShop affiliate* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Putters | Putters | Putters |
| Fit profile | Stability and alignment | Soft face value | Tour-milled precision |
| Score | 97 | 97 | 97 |
| Est. used price | $125 | $165 | $215 |
| Value index | 326 | 247 | 189 |
| Forgiveness | 80 | 70 | 80 |
| Speed | 83 | 81 | 83 |
| Feel | 69 | 76 | 76 |
| Value rating | 93 | 92 | 83 |
| Launch | Start line | Start line | Low to mid |
| Spin | Feedback | Feedback | Controllable |
| Best for | Golfers who prefer compact shapes, toe flow, and sharper feedback. | Golfers who prefer compact shapes, toe flow, and sharper feedback. | Consistent ball strikers who value feedback, shape control, and precise gapping. |
| Watch out | Match toe hang, length, loft, lie, and grip shape to your stroke. | Match toe hang, length, loft, lie, and grip shape to your stroke. | Do not buy only by model name. Confirm loft, lie, length, shaft, grip size, and condition. |
Putters comparison table
Sort priority is editorial score, value index, release year, and brand. Verify exact specs, condition, shaft, loft, lie, and grip before buying any used equipment.
| Year | Brand | Model family | Fit profile | Score | Est. used | Value | Affiliate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | TaylorMade | Spider XA smaller, cleaner Spider that became a massive retail hit. | Stability and alignment | 97 | $125 | 326 | Shop* |
| 2021 | Cleveland | HB Soft PremierA clean finish and strong value proposition. | Soft face value | 97 | $165 | 247 | Shop* |
| 2022 | PING | PLD MilledPremium milled putters with serious fitting credibility. | Tour-milled precision | 97 | $215 | 189 | Shop* |
| 2025 | Bettinardi | Studio Stock 2025A compact premium family for traditional setups. | Feel and roll | 97 | $330 | 123 | Shop* |
| 2025 | TaylorMade | Spider Tour refreshThe core Spider story stayed centered on MOI and alignment. | Mallet stability | 97 | $330 | 123 | Shop* |
| 2026 | TaylorMade | Spider currentTaylorMade's putter identity remains Spider-led for mallet players. | High-MOI stability | 97 | $385 | 106 | Shop* |
| 2018 | Bettinardi | Studio StockA fine-feel line for players who value milling feedback. | Soft carbon feel | 96 | $105 | 384 | Shop* |
| 2020 | Odyssey | Triple Track / TenTriple Track lines and Ten mallets simplified aim for many players. | Alignment mallets | 96 | $145 | 278 | Shop* |
| 2022 | L.A.B. Golf | LINK.1A blade-style answer for golfers curious about lie-angle balance. | Blade low torque | 96 | $195 | 207 | Shop* |
| 2023 | PING | 2023 PuttersA practical lineup across Anser, Tyne, and mallet shapes. | Feel and fit matrix | 96 | $250 | 161 | Shop* |
| 2020 | Cleveland | FrontlineA different MOI approach with tungsten forward weighting. | Forward CG stability | 95 | $145 | 275 | Shop* |
| 2023 | Bettinardi | Queen B 2023A premium fit for players chasing feel and finish. | Milled elegance | 95 | $225 | 177 | Shop* |
| 2023 | Odyssey | Versa / Jailbird / ToulonJailbird demand surged while Versa lines remained useful. | Alignment and tour shapes | 95 | $225 | 177 | Shop* |
| 2024 | Bettinardi | BB Series 2024Refined milling and alignment in familiar profiles. | Classic precision | 95 | $265 | 151 | Shop* |
| 2025 | PING | ScottsdaleA broad family with value and fit clarity. | Soft insert alignment | 95 | $365 | 109 | Shop* |
| 2026 | L.A.B. Golf | OZ.1A newer low-torque mallet entry gaining equipment attention. | Modern low torque | 94 | $385 | 103 | Shop* |
| 2017 | Odyssey | O-WorksMicrohinge inserts made roll consistency the headline. | Microhinge roll | 93 | $90 | 434 | Shop* |
| 2018 | Scotty Cameron | Select 2018A compact blade and mid-mallet refresh. | Refined insert feel | 93 | $115 | 340 | Shop* |
| 2021 | Bettinardi | InovaiA more forgiving mallet direction within the premium space. | High-MOI mallets | 93 | $165 | 237 | Shop* |
| 2022 | Scotty Cameron | Phantom X 2022A broad mallet family with premium finish. | Alignment and MOI | 93 | $215 | 182 | Shop* |
| 2023 | Scotty Cameron | Super SelectA crisp milled family with refined necks and weights. | Blade and mid-mallet precision | 93 | $250 | 156 | Shop* |
| 2021 | L.A.B. Golf | MEZZ.1A more compact entry into L.A.B.'s face-stability concept. | Compact low torque | 92 | $165 | 234 | Shop* |
| 2016 | Odyssey | White Hot RXA familiar Odyssey feel profile for golfers who like muted feedback. | Soft insert feel | 91 | $80 | 478 | Shop* |
| 2016 | TaylorMade | Spider TourA tour-validated mallet that shaped the modern putter market. | High-MOI mallet | 91 | $80 | 478 | Shop* |
| 2021 | Odyssey | White Hot OGThe classic White Hot feel returned with modern shafts. | Classic insert revival | 91 | $165 | 232 | Shop* |
| 2025 | Odyssey | Square 2 SquareA low-torque lineup for golfers wanting less face rotation. | Low-torque stability | 91 | $330 | 116 | Shop* |
| 2026 | PING | Scottsdale TECWhite-black alignment and onset models targeted modern aiming trends. | Eye Q alignment | 91 | $420 | 91 | Shop* |
| 2020 | Scotty Cameron | Special SelectA cleaner return to solid stainless milled feedback. | Solid milled feel | 90 | $160 | 236 | Shop* |
| 2021 | Scotty Cameron | Phantom X refreshMore shapes for straight-to-arc strokes. | Mallet stability | 90 | $185 | 204 | Shop* |
| 2016 | Scotty Cameron | SelectClassic Newport-led family with familiar milled feedback. | Milled blade feel | 89 | $85 | 440 | Shop* |
| 2017 | TaylorMade | TP CollectionBlade and mid-mallet shapes for traditionalists. | Classic milled shapes | 89 | $90 | 415 | Shop* |
| 2019 | Odyssey | Stroke LabThe multi-material shaft made tempo and head awareness the story. | Stroke-balanced shafting | 88 | $125 | 296 | Shop* |
| 2021 | TaylorMade | Spider EX / Spider GTMore visual alignment and a broader mallet family. | Forgiveness and face tech | 88 | $165 | 224 | Shop* |
| 2024 | L.A.B. Golf | DF3A cleaner, easier-to-fit DF evolution. | Forgiving low torque | 88 | $265 | 139 | Shop* |
| 2024 | Odyssey | Ai-ONE / Ai-ONE MilledFace design aimed to preserve speed on off-center putts. | AI insert consistency | 88 | $265 | 139 | Shop* |
| 2025 | Scotty Cameron | Studio StyleA softer insert direction in familiar blade and mallet forms. | Carbon steel insert feel | 88 | $365 | 101 | Shop* |
| 2017 | PING | Sigma GA responsive insert family with many shapes. | Soft insert feel | 87 | $100 | 365 | Shop* |
| 2020 | PING | HepplerA firmer, colorful contrast to Sigma's soft insert. | Firm feel and alignment | 87 | $160 | 228 | Shop* |
| 2021 | PING | 2021 PuttersClear fit codes helped golfers match arc and shape. | Stroke-type fitting | 87 | $185 | 198 | Shop* |
| 2016 | Cleveland | Huntington BeachA standout affordable milled option. | Value milled feel | 86 | $80 | 452 | Shop* |
| 2023 | Cleveland | HB Soft 2A smart budget line with consistent distance control. | Speed optimized face | 86 | $225 | 161 | Shop* |
| 2016 | Bettinardi | BB SeriesPremium milling with classic blade and mallet shapes. | Milled feel | 85 | $80 | 446 | Shop* |
| 2018 | Odyssey | EXO / Red BallA strong mallet period with visible alignment aids. | High-MOI alignment | 85 | $105 | 340 | Shop* |
| 2024 | Scotty Cameron | PhantomUpdated Phantom shapes improved confidence behind the ball. | Compact mallet stability | 85 | $290 | 123 | Shop* |
| 2017 | Scotty Cameron | FuturaLarger mallets made Scotty's stability story more visible. | High-MOI mallets | 84 | $100 | 353 | Shop* |
| 2018 | PING | Sigma 2PING made length fitting especially easy. | Adjustable-length fitting | 84 | $115 | 307 | Shop* |
| 2019 | Scotty Cameron | Phantom XPhantom X brought bolder mallet geometry. | Modern mallet alignment | 84 | $135 | 261 | Shop* |
| 2020 | Bettinardi | Queen BDistinct finishes and soft shapes for feel-first golfers. | Premium shapes | 84 | $145 | 243 | Shop* |
| 2024 | TaylorMade | Spider Tour / X / ZA return to Spider's strongest silhouettes. | Tour mallet refresh | 84 | $265 | 133 | Shop* |
| 2026 | Scotty Cameron | Phantom 2026A full-face Studio Carbon Steel insert and modern mallet geometry. | Modern mallet feel | 84 | $420 | 84 | Shop* |
| 2018 | Cleveland | TFi 2135 Satin2135 alignment positioned the line for golfers who struggle with eye setup. | Alignment help | 83 | $105 | 332 | Shop* |
| 2018 | L.A.B. Golf | Directed Force 2.1A distinctive low-torque shape that built a devoted following. | Lie-angle balanced | 83 | $105 | 332 | Shop* |
| 2020 | TaylorMade | Truss / Spider STruss necks and Spider S expanded TaylorMade's putter menu. | Stability experiments | 83 | $145 | 240 | Shop* |
| 2023 | TaylorMade | TP ReserveA more premium milled direction for classic shapes. | Milled premium | 83 | $225 | 155 | Shop* |
| 2026 | Odyssey | Ai-DUALCurrent Odyssey lineup with Ai-DUAL and Square 2 Square options. | Dual insert alignment | 83 | $385 | 91 | Shop* |
| 2022 | Odyssey | Tri-Hot 5K / ElevenA major push toward high-MOI blades and mallets. | Blade-like MOI | 82 | $195 | 177 | Shop* |
| 2022 | TaylorMade | Spider GT Rollback / NotchbackDifferent CG and hosel choices made fitting easier. | Shape variety | 82 | $195 | 177 | Shop* |
| 2016 | PING | VaultA premium milled family with classic Anser DNA. | Milled premium | 81 | $85 | 400 | Shop* |
Price vs performance
Dots open reviews* As an Amazon Associate, Every18 earns from qualifying purchases. Some links here are affiliate links — using them costs you nothing extra, and it never affects our course ratings.
